GracieMadelyn
2024-05-07 19:50:59 GMT
Pudgie's is always amazing, and we were so happy to find another location! The service was good - we found the stash of spice shakers ourselves over by the dining room entrance instead of on our tables, which was something we had to figure out, I guess. And I have never seen such a collection of taxidermy before.....kinda odd...still processing that....
Brandon Parsell
2023-12-16 23:12:30 GMT
Best pizza in Canandaigua, love the wings. Been going here since I was a kid. The restaurant has an awesome collection of trophy mounts on display as well.
Steve Gonzalez
2023-12-04 02:53:32 GMT
Always have had a great experience with pudgies! I remember going there as kids back in the 70s. When our parents moved us out to Canandaigua, from Rochester. I have personally gotten to know the sons of the owner ( great people). I still go there to this day. I'm happy that they still exist in our area!!!
Kayla Pizura
2022-11-10 14:46:47 GMT
Of course I got the mild barbecue wings and I ate in which was a great experience. It's crazy that 20 wings were $30 but I will pay it because I love the wings.
Joel Thompson
2024-04-04 00:31:15 GMT
Hadn’t had a Pudgie pizza or Pudgie Burger in a long time. Man, it was the best! I will return soon, it was delicious.
Kevin Sullivan
2024-02-12 22:08:42 GMT
Great pizza, as always. Wings were excellent! Best wings I've had in awhile!! Service was exceptional!
Ann Marie Mansfield
2024-04-29 14:33:06 GMT
Great pizza, employees were polite and quick to assist.
Ron Bergeron
2023-09-28 22:23:36 GMT
The pizza here is the best pizza I've ever had. The service is very good and the prices are very reasonable. Every time I take my dad to the VA Medical Center in Canandaigua, we always stop in for a slice of pizza or one of their fantastic Italian specials. If you ever happen to be in Canandaigua, NY, you have to make sure you stop in to Pudgies on Main Street. You won't be disappointed.
Kristtyy Grotta (KinkyAcademicSexologist)
2023-09-05 11:04:08 GMT
One of my favorite pizza places growing up in Elmira/Corning/ Area as a child. Now this is the closest Pudgies and they did not let me down when I visited. The pizza and Stromboli are still just as awesome as they ever were. Outstanding. Also on top of it they still had some 90’s feel to this location with some old school arcade games. Like a childhood dream come true, and now we’ve got our next generation of kids hooked on them too after the vacation visit. Thanks Pudgies. Keep killing it.
Andrew Bliss
2024-04-23 17:59:15 GMT
pudgies is my all time favorite pizza place in Canandaigua, best pizza and wings.
Brian Weaver
2023-06-11 13:55:02 GMT
Drove from Buffalo to there because my granddaughters love pudgies pizza. Round trip 4 hrs. Ordered sheet pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese it was good. Ordered a pudgie burger it was good. Order a 3 cheese stromboli and it wasn't what we ordered it was 3 meat which we don't eat. If we wanted meat it would only have been pepperoni. We don't eat ham or sausage ever on pizza. Very disappointed spent 4 hrs in the road, $92 for food plus gas only to have the order wrong. Not like it was down the road to go back and get it fixed.
Kevin Lyon
2024-02-01 10:13:24 GMT
Food was good. Service was great fast and accurate.
Michelle Quagliata
2023-12-23 00:38:46 GMT
I loved my sub.on Thursday it's so good thank you very much.
Jessi templar
2023-07-05 21:10:10 GMT
Absolutely wonderful. The food was ready early, the staff was great, everything was tasty! The family got pizza, which was devoured, and we got subs, which were amazing!
Trevor VanHoose
2022-10-13 20:09:07 GMT
My bf wanted to take me here for years. Happy we finally went. Got breadsticks w sauce, 2 fountain drinks, and a deep dish w bacon. Everything I wanted and more! Can't wait to come back when I'm in the area again.
Yaro S
2020-09-25 22:58:03 GMT
Unique taste that brings me back to the place over and over through the years. This is not “authentic” NY or CT style pizza...it’s its very own kind. Dough has just the right crisp on the bottom and is delightfully chewy on top. Whatever magic they use to keep the same unique taste over the decades hasn’t been replicated locally to my knowledge. Service is always great. Call ahead for large orders.
Jeremy Lloyd
2023-03-16 17:38:00 GMT
Just a classic staple pizza joint. Some of the best there is! I've been going to this particular location since 1993 when my grandma would take me there for the 2 slice special after picking me up from school when I was in 2nd grade. Great memories, fantastic service, and even more stellar pizza! UPDATE 3/16/2023 --> Still fantastic!
Andi D
2020-03-09 00:01:39 GMT
Oh my can I just say I love meatball subs. I am always interested in meatballs. And let me tell you their meatballs are amazing. Service was great, the person who took my order joked with us the whole time. A very friendly environment. Although all of the animal heads on the walls weren't my favorite. But with such a good meatball sub who cares? 100% recommend
Bobbie Morey
2018-12-14 01:48:15 GMT
AWESOME PIZZA!! My husband grew up on this pizza and our daughters beg for it every trip to NY! Especially Canandaigua, NY!!!
Sammy DCib
2024-02-13 13:45:26 GMT
Excellent pizza, and good prices.
